Drawing on Young Adult Literature to Facilitate Mental Health Literacy: Reading The Words We Keep with Pre-Service Teacher by Rachel Wolney and Ashley Boyd
Rachael R. Wolney is a fourth year Ph.D. candidate in the Department of English at Washington State University. Her research interests include Disability Studies, Young Adult Literature, and Education. She teaches using disability studies pedagogy in a range of literature and writing courses, but specifically enjoys working with preservice teachers and practicing teachers in learning about disability. |
Ashley S. Boyd is an associate professor of English education at Washington State University where she teaches courses on English Methods and Young Adult Literature and researches practicing teachers’ social justice pedagogies as well as avenues for cultivating students’ critical literacies. She is author of Social Justice Literacies in the English Classroom and co-author (with Janine J. Darragh) of Reading for Justice: Engaging Middle Level Readers in Social Action through Young Adult Literature. |
Mental health literacy works to help both teachers and students identify mental health issues and promotes the process of seeking out help from professionals in support of mental health wellness. It positions the teacher as facilitator, normalizes conversations about mental health, and provides resources for teachers and students alike. We feel that MHL exists alongside other crucial social justice literacies (Boyd, 2017, Hines & Johnson, 2007) that should be cultivated in classrooms, and thus we offer here our own inclusion of discussions of mental health with English Education pre-service candidates. We detail our experiences teaching the young adult novel, The Words We Keep by Erin Stewart and suggest that young adult literature (YAL) can accompany guided critical conversations that can promote MHL in the English Language Arts (ELA) classroom. Following others in the field (e.g. Monaghan, 2016; Olan & Richmond, 2023; Richmond, 2018), we believe that YAL can be a powerful mechanism for broaching oft-considered sensitive topics, especially mental health, which are often avoided or feared in classrooms. We offer here our successes in implementing this course content and possible ideas and cautions to aid teachers in their own endeavors to destigmatize mental health issues. |
Young Adult Literature as a Facilitator for Mental Health Literacy
Our Course and Mental Health
Using YAL to facilitate our discussions of mental health, we incorporate several texts that involve varied storylines. For instance, we read The Serpent King (Zenter, 2017) as well as Darius the Great is Not Okay (Khorram, 2018) and discuss the characters’ struggles with depression, amongst other themes. For this YA Wednesday blog, we focus on one of our weeklong units in our YAL course that occurs approximately in the middle of the semester (of a 15-week course). By week six, students have already been introduced to the field of YAL and to our overarching social justice centered curriculum, which includes discussions of race, class, gender, disability/ability as well as societal oppression, intersectionality, and privilege. At this halfway point, students are familiar with classroom expectations and have engaged in respectful and critical conversations with peers about these social topics. In reference to the assigned readings and critical in-class discussions, students are also required to purposefully complete multiple individual and group related assignments, including a research paper, a multimedia project, and a social action project. These projects are scaffolded by daily activities and teaching opportunities where students lead the day’s class discussion. Our courses aim to promote action, a fundamental part of Megan Boler’s (1999) discussion of the “Pedagogy of Discomfort,” as both a place of inquiry and the call to action at critical moments in learning processes (p. 179). We discuss complicity and ask our students to engage in action-based learning where they think critically about how texts can inform lived experiences and challenge spaces outside of the classroom. |
The Words We Keep (Stewart, 2022) follows two sisters through their intense struggles with mental illness. Lily, the younger sister, has anxiety and desires to live a “normal” life. Lily’s story begins as her sister Alice returns home from a treatment program where she was diagnosed and medicated for bipolar disorder. Lily remembers Alice’s traumatic suicide attempt and sees the burden of her diagnosis on the family, especially her father, but she sees even more how different Alice is after she returns. Alice doesn’t have her previous flair, and her personality is muted. She no longer dons her brightly colored clothing or has eccentric plans or enthusiasm. Instead, Alice is withdrawn and distant. Under close supervision of their father, Alice is not allowed to be alone; all sharp objects have been hidden; and there is a tension in their home as the family supports and navigates Alice’s diagnosis. In the midst of Alice’s mental health crisis, Lily feels like she has to be perfect. She spends most of her time worried about getting into college and being the model daughter to support her sister and family. This exacerbates her anxiety throughout the text and even though she meets Micah, a new student at her school (who also attended the same treatment center as her sister), she feels alone. Throughout the novel, Lily uses art as a way of expressing the ‘words we keep’ inside, hidden, and private. As her school poetry project unfolds, Lily finds that she is not alone in her experiences. Lily, Alice, and Micah journey through the unknowns of mental health issues and face the stigmas surrounding mental health to find that their journey together is what matters most. This exceptional novel is raw and descriptive of what mental illness can look like in multiple forms–through Lily’s anxiety, Micah’s depression, and Alice’s bipolar disorder.
Students’ reading of this novel was divided into two sections, with half the novel assigned per class meeting. During the halfway mark, students reported that: they loved the text and couldn’t put it down, had completed the novel already, or felt that the content was so vividly descriptive that they had to take multiple breaks and were behind schedule. Some students shared that the novel was graphic and brought up their own experiences with trauma, but they felt that the content was accurate in its portrayal. Even though they knew that everyone experiences mental health related issues differently, the students shared that they enjoyed the accuracy of the text based on their own understanding of the elements within the novel. While some expressed that the novel was difficult to read, each student did successfully complete the reading and stated that while it brought up hard issues, they were important topics to discuss in the classroom. They understood that mental health issues impact a large portion of the population and expect that they will encounter people in their lives and in their future classrooms who are in crisis. The students appreciated the additional resources delivered with the unit. Some students, interested in writing a novel themselves, went on to have further discussions of mental health representations and the need for more accuracy to fight against stigmas of mental health. Some students identified with having anxiety and resonated with the depictions of Lily feeling like she needed to be perfect. Others understood the realities of bipolar disorder. Ultimately, students repeatedly expressed that while the text might be difficult to read, it facilitated healthy conversations about mental health, representation, stigma, and access to resources.
As noted above, MHL has expanded to incorporate four major components: 1) to maintain positive mental health; 2) to identify and understand disorders and treatment; 3) to reduce the stigma of mental health issues and seek out help; and 4) to supply essential resources for support and seeking help (Eisenback & Frydman, 2003, p. 2). Our unit attempted to address these elements through reading, research, and discussion. We provided resources at the outset of the unit and offered data on the prevalence of mental health issues, definitions of various types of diagnoses, and practices for establishing mental well-being. As also mentioned above, we focused extensively on the authenticity of the narrative and how Stewart’s (2022) representation revealed and debunked common stigmas. Olan and Richmond (2023) write, “many texts featuring characters with mental illness include authors’ language and descriptions which perpetuate stigma via the readers’ positioning of the characters through a deficit narrative model … In YAL, for example, this could mean characters with mental illness are written as not having effective relationships, not fitting in, experiencing violence/harassment, being positioned as victims, experiencing social isolation, or having negative futures” (p. 22). We asked students how The Words We Keep worked against such tropes.
References
Appleman, D. (2022). Literature and the new culture wars: Triggers, cancel culture, and the teacher’s dilemma. Norton
Bishop, R. S. (1990). Mirrors, windows, and sliding glass doors. Perspectives – Gerontological Nursing Association, 6(3), ix–xi.
Boler, M. (1999). Feeling power: Emotions and education. Taylor & Francis Group.
Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). (2023, December). Promoting mental health and well-being in schools: An action guide for school and district leaders. DASH. file:///C:/Users/hrsw4/OneDrive/Documents/DASH_MH_Action_Guide_508.pdf
Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). (2024, May 1). Adolescent and School Health. https://www.cdc.gov/healthyyouth/mental-health/index.htm
Boyd, A. (2017). Social justice literacies in the English classroom: Teaching practice in
action. Teachers College Press.
Boyd, A. & Darragh, J. (2019). Critical literacies on the university campus: Engaging pre-
service teachers with social action projects. English Teaching: Practice & Critique,
19(1), 49-63.
Duszynski-Goodman, L., & Henderson, L. (2024, February 21). Mental health statistics and facts. Forbes Health. https://www.forbes.com/health/mind/mental-health-statistics/#footnote_5
Eisenback, B. B., & Frydman, J. S. (2023). What are we doing?: Teacher role confusion in mental health literacy education. Teaching and Teacher Education, 132, 1-12. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2023.104236
Eisenback, B. B., & Frydman, J. S. (2024). Integrating mental health literacy in the English language arts middle school classroom. Middle School Journal, 55(3), 5-15.
Falter, M. (2022). When the shoe doesn’t fit: A critical empathy framework for young adult literature instruction. The ALAN Review, 50 (1), 18-32.
Ginsberg, R. & Glenn, W. J. (2019). Moments of pause: Understanding students’ shifting perceptions during a Muslim young adult literature learning experience. Reading Research Quaterly, 55(4), 601-623.
Goodfellow, C. (2022, March 4). Mental health literacy in schools: Let’s talk about how we talk about mental health. Education Today. https://www.educationtoday.com.au/news-detail/Mental-Health-Literacy-in-Schools-5540#:~:text=Mental%20health%20literacy%20was%20first%20defined
Hines, M. B.& Johnson, J. (2007). Teachers and students as agents of change: Toward a taxonomy of the literacies of social justice. In D. Row, R. Jimenez, D. Compton, D. Dickinson, Y. Kim, K. Leander, & V. Risko (Eds.), 2007 Yearbook of the National Reading Conference (pp. 281-292). Oak Creek, WI: National Reading Conference.
Khorram, A. (2018). Darius the great is not okay. Penguin Books.
Kutcher, S. Wei, Y. W. & Coniglio, C. (2016). Mental health literacy: Past, present, and future. The Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 61(3), 154-158.
Monaghan, A. (2016). Evaluating representations of mental health in young adult fiction: The case of Stephen Chbosky’s The Perks of Being a Wallflower. Enthymema, XVI, 32-42.
Olan, E. L. & Richmond, K.J. (2023). Narrative of deficit and authentic portrayals of mental illness and cultural sensitivities in young adult literature. Study and Scrutiny: Research in Young Adult Literature, 61(1).
Richmond, K. J. (2018). Mental illness in young adult literature: Exploring real struggles through fictional characters. Libraries Unlimited.
Sherr, M., & Beise, B. (2015). Using young adult literature to enhance empathy skills: Preliminary findings in BSW education. Journal of Baccalaureate Social Work, 20(1), 101-110.
Webber, K. & Agiro, C. P. (2019). Not from around these parts: Using young adult literature to promote empathy for the immigrant experience. Talking Points, 30 (2), 2-9.
Zentner, J. (2017). The serpent king. Random House.