Meet Our Contributor
| Melanie Shoffner is a professor of English education at James Madison University, where she regularly teaches secondary ELA methods, curriculum theory, and English literature - all of which include YA lit. She is the editor of English Education and the co-/editor of seven books; her most recent work has appeared in The Educational Forum and Reflective Practice. |
Famous First Words by Melanie Shoffner
The best opening sentences are a form of authorial magic. They bring us into the offered story by linking truth and fiction in ways that speak directly to us. None of us have lived through the French Revolution, after all, but we have experienced the dissonance of living in a beautiful world as it is torn apart by madness and malice, so clearly captured in Dickens’s opening to A Tale of Two Cities.
Why These Choices?
Some of these novels have made their way into my courses through the years. The Girl and the Ghost and Wolf Hollow fit nicely in middle school ELA methods, providing foundational texts for preservice teachers’ work with reader engagement (e.g., Bundick et al., 2014), diversity in curriculum (e.g., Ebarvia et al., 2020), and empathy (e.g., Vogt et al., 2016) in their future teaching.
Blood, Water, Paint worked well in a general education English course, introducing the concept of a novel in verse (e.g., Hundley, 2026) while supporting students’ exploration into issues of resistance and power. I have used other YA novels in this course, each of them wielding their hook with an initial sentence, like Samira Ahmed’s “You never forget the first time you see a dead body” in Hollow Fires and Angelina Boulley’s “I am a frozen statue of a girl in the woods” in Firekeeper’s Daughter. Yet, Blood, Water, Paint remains the favorite when I ask students which books to keep, perhaps because the novel’s first words strike a chord that the others do not.
Each of these five novels--Wolf Hollow; Echo Mountain; Salt to the Sea; Blood, Water, Paint; The Girl and the Ghost—begins with words that capture a reader’s attention and connect to a reader’s interior life. What does it mean to lie? How do we demonstrate love? Why do we choose to hurt others? What is the truth in a world of different perspectives? What if, indeed, ghosts are real? However they may be used, whoever may choose to read them, YA novels that cause us to question…something…from the very first words are YA novels we need to read.
References
Bundick, M. J., Quaglia, R. J., Corso, M. J., & Haywood, D. E. (2014). Promoting student engagement in the classroom. Teachers College Record, 116(4), 1–34.
Ebarvia, T., Germán, L., Parker, K. N., & Torres, J. (2020). #DisruptTexts. English Journal, 110(1), 100–102.
Hundley, M. (2026). The young adult verse novel: Marching to its own beat. In V. Malo-Juvera & C. Hill (Eds), The Oxford handbook of young adult literature. Oxford Academic. https://doi.org/10.1093/9780191945540.003.0018
Snider, G. (2018, June 27). Books are… Incidental Comics. http://www.incidentalcomics.com/2018/06/books-are.html
Vogt, M. T., Chow, Y. P., Fernandez, J., Grubman, C., & Stacey, D. (2016). Designing a reading curriculum to teach the concept of empathy to middle level learners. Voices from the Middle, 23(4), 38–45.
Works Referenced
Alkaf, H. (2022). The girl and the ghost. Harper Collins.
Boulley, A. (2021). Firekeeper’s daughter. Henry Holt and Co.
McCullough, J. (2019). Blood, water, paint. Penguin Books.
Sepetys, R. (2016). Salt to the sea. Philomel Books.
Wolk, L (2021) Echo mountain. Dutton Books for Young Readers.
Wolk, L (2018) Wolf hollow. Puffin Books
RSS Feed